Engraving, 100 x 146 mm. Meder 36, 1b-c (of 2), Bartsch 40, Strauss 78. Impression of the 1st state (of 2) before the reworks in particular on the wall and the Child’s cheek. Meder distinguishes three issues for the first state impressions (a, b and c). He does not specify any clear difference between b and c impressions, and the scratches he notes on b impressions are the same as those on c impressions. The difference lies rather in the watermarks found by Meder, which he dates to around 1525 for b impressions and around 1560-1570 for c impressions. Our impression is intermediate between b and c: the scratch reported on the Virgin's drapery is not visible and the one between the tower and the building is barely visible. The dating of the watermark to around 1550 confirms this b-c identification. Fine, uniform silver impression printed on watermarked laid paper. Watermark similar to Meder 46, crown above the city's coat of arms with three towers, which Joseph Meder dates to c. 1550. Excellent condition. Small remnants of mounting paper on the reverse in the corners. Thread margins all around the platemark. 'The Virgin and Child Seated by the Wall' is one of the most beautiful Madonnas with Child engraved by Dürer. For Erwin Panofsky, it represents a culmination of Dürer's work: ‘The acme of perfection—perfection inasmuch as Dürer succeeded in fusing widely divergent tendencies without a sacrifice of either harmony, as in the preceding years, or concreteness and variety, as in later years—was reached in 1514. Compared with the vivid Virgin with the Pear of 1511 (148) on the one hand, and with the stony Virgin with the Swaddled Infant of 1520 (145, fig. 251) on the other, the Virgin by the Wall (147) represents indeed a perfect coincidence of apparent opposites. Regal and virginal, yet humble and motherly, the Virgin Mary is depicted in an environment in which a sense of sheltered intimacy blends with the freedom of the open spaces. The utmost precision of design is combined with an incomparable softness of texture. The lines and strokes, while fulfilling the difficult and varied tasks of modelling form, of indicating direction (as the converging hatchings of the foreshortened walls and the parallel hatchings of the sloping roof), of suggesting luminary values, and of characterizing surface qualities (as in the woolen stuff and silken lining of the Virgin’s mantle), yet maintain what may be called their graphic integrity. The deepest shadows, like the ones above the Virgin’s right knee and beneath her neat “Hausfrau’s” purse, are so small in compass and so softly embedded amidst other areas of varying darkness that they do not impair the impression of perfect transparency and homogeneity. The whole engraving, though far from being lusterless, shimmers with the soft, cool tones of mat silver.’ (Erwin Panofsky, Albrecht Dürer, 1945, vol 1, p. 150) The Virgin and Child Seated by the Wall has often been compared to Melencolia I, also engraved in 1514, one of the three Meisterstiche engraved by Dürer in 1513 and 1514. Walter L. Strauss recognises the same tragic atmosphere in both works, which he links to the death of Dürer's mother in May 1514. The composition of the prints is also very similar. Two similar pairs, the Virgin and Child on the one hand, and the two winged figures in Melencolia I on the other, occupy a similar position in a similarly structured environment: they are seated at the foot of a wall that forms the right-hand background of the engraving, while on the left the eye is drawn to a distant landscape. In the case of Melencolia I, it is a town on the edge of a lake, while behind the Virgin ‘appears the castle of Nuremberg, which Dürer could see from the windows of his house.’ (Strauss, no. 78) The keys and purse attached to the Virgin's belt are also a direct echo of Melencolia I, as the angel carries similar items. However, there is no trace of the many enigmatic objects that fill the space around the figures in Melencolia I: on the ground, there are only a few small stones that have fallen from the crumbling steps and a tuft of grass at the foot of a low wall. References: Erwin Panofsky, Albrecht Dürer, 1945; Walter L. Strauss: The Complete Engravings, Etchings and Drypoints of Albrecht Dürer, 1972.